Many Seattle intersections lack accessible crossing indicators for individuals with imaginative and prescient or listening to loss


Jessica Thompson is accustomed to shut calls. 

On the intersection close to her rental in North Seattle, she steps to the sting of the curb and listens. When it sounds protected, she steps into the road. 

“I’ve individuals honking at me and yelling at me on a regular basis,” Thompson mentioned. “They assume I’d be taking note of the cross[ing] mild.”

Thompson, who’s blind, can’t depend on the sunshine. As an alternative, she listens to site visitors patterns to find out when drivers are slowing and stopping on the intersection at Northeast ninety fifth Avenue and Fifth Avenue Northeast. 

Visitors Lab is a Seattle Instances challenge that digs into the area’s thorny transportation points, spotlights promising approaches to easing gridlock, and helps readers discover one of the best methods to get round. It’s funded with the assistance of neighborhood sponsors Alaska Airways, Kemper Improvement Co., Madrona Enterprise Group, NHL Seattle, PEMCO Mutual Insurance coverage Firm and Seattle Youngsters’s hospital. Seattle Instances editors and reporters function independently of our funders and keep editorial management over Visitors Lab content material.

At some crossings, audible indicators beep to let her comprehend it’s protected to cross.

However in Seattle, the overwhelming majority of pedestrian indicators don’t have audible sounds for people who find themselves blind and low imaginative and prescient. This intersection close to Thompson’s rental was lately upgraded with new sidewalks and curb cuts, however nonetheless has the outdated pedestrian sign. 

Visitors there may be mild or erratic, making it exhausting for Thompson to get a very good learn on whether or not vehicles have stopped. 

“The quieter intersections may be the scarier ones when individuals are going quick,” she mentioned. 

A wave of inhabitants development and transportation funding in Seattle has led to what seems like nonstop building across the metropolis and loads of newly rebuilt intersections, many with accessibility in thoughts. A federal consent decree requires Seattle to put in 1,250 new curb ramps per yr for individuals who use wheelchairs and different mobility units. 

Town doesn’t face an identical authorized mandate for Accessible Pedestrian Indicators, which make a sound and vibrate for individuals who have imaginative and prescient or listening to loss.

Greater than three quarters of Seattle’s indicators wouldn’t have such units.

The Seattle Division of Transportation (SDOT) says it’s putting in accessible indicators as town has the funding and utilizing suggestions from individuals with disabilities to prioritize the place to improve first. 

Thompson crosses Fifth Avenue Northeast often to get to the espresso store, pharmacy, chiropractor’s workplace and bus cease. Strolling permits her to get round with out counting on another person.

“However,” she mentioned, “I would like to have the ability to cross the road.”

New indicators not all the time required

When crews spent months rebuilding sidewalks and crosswalks close to Thompson’s rental, she heard the challenge was centered on “accessibility.” She lives close to an elementary faculty and the Northgate mild rail station set to open subsequent yr. So she assumed the sign would get replaced.

Improved sidewalks and intersections don’t all the time end in a brand new pedestrian sign.

Although federal guidelines require cities like Seattle to put in accessible indicators after they exchange outdated indicators or set up new ones, crews can renovate massive components of an intersection with out changing the pedestrian sign itself. 

A 2017 SDOT memo attracts a distinction between a sign that’s “considerably altered” and different varieties of work, like putting in curb ramps or shifting the pedestrian push button.

Seattle’s lack of accessible indicators “doesn’t present significant entry” as required by the Individuals with Disabilities Act, argued Susan Kas, an lawyer at Incapacity Rights Washington, which filed the 2015 lawsuit that resulted in Seattle agreeing to construct new curb ramps.

Incapacity Rights Washington has not introduced an identical swimsuit about accessible crossings.

Advocates in New York and in Chicago have sued over a scarcity of accessible indicators.

SDOT has elevated the variety of accessible indicators lately. Town put in 30 of the indicators in 2018 and 66 in 2019, SDOT mentioned. At this time, accessible indicators make up about 22% of town’s signalized intersections, up from about 15% in 2017

The associated fee to put in accessible indicators can fluctuate extensively relying on how a lot different work, like digging underground or repairing sidewalks, is required.

SDOT estimates that every accessible sign improve prices roughly $50,000 for supplies, labor and related work like sidewalk repairs. Some places can value far roughly, from $10,000 to $100,000 every, based on SDOT.

The division’s annual price range for Individuals with Disabilities Act (ADA) initiatives consists of about $500,000 for about 10 accessible indicators per yr. Extra indicators are upgraded as a part of different initiatives, like transit upgrades.

Though SDOT has not produced a proper research of upgrading indicators, at $50,000 every, upgrading all 875 crossings with out accessible indicators would value about $44 million.

Backlog of requests

Charlie Howe, a highschool sophomore who lives in North Capitol Hill, makes use of a number of busy intersections to get to the bus. 

At tenth Avenue East and Miller Avenue, “it’s difficult as a result of individuals are turning left, individuals turning proper. It seems like vehicles go approach too quick by means of the intersection,” Howe mentioned.

Howe’s sight has worsened within the final yr and he has bother seeing stroll indicators, particularly on brilliant days, he mentioned. He makes use of a white cane however worries some drivers don’t see it. 

This summer season, he submitted a request for accessible indicators to SDOT and acquired a response saying town was working by means of its three-year plan of places to improve indicators. It’s not clear when town might get to the indicators he requested. 

“[I feel] a bit pissed off as a result of that’s form of a very long time for me to attend,” Howe mentioned. “It actually shouldn’t take that lengthy.”

SDOT has a backlog of requests, many on behalf of blind or low-vision Seattleites for places close to their houses or work. The company consults with an advisory group of individuals with disabilities to prioritize the requests.

Howe’s request is one among about 70 excellent, based on a replica of SDOT’s request log obtained by means of a public information request. SDOT prioritized 29 of these for accessible indicators from 2019 to 2021. Further indicators are upgraded by means of common building.

Different requests have been marked with anticipated building dates in 2025 or 2026, or don’t but have any estimate for after they’ll be accomplished.

Areas downtown on Pike Avenue at First, Second and Third avenues embody a word from SDOT’s ADA director, Michael Shaw: “These have been requested a number of instances. They’re mainly floor zero for vacationers.” (The places are marked for brand new indicators in 2026.)

When Michael Forzano was commuting every day to his job at Amazon in South Lake Union, many intersections alongside the way in which had accessible indicators. Then, simply earlier than his workplace, he’d get to Ninth and Mercer. Forzano is blind and has listening to loss, making studying the sound of site visitors exhausting “even underneath very best circumstances,” he mentioned.

Some days, he would use a call-in service to video chat with somebody who may inform him when it was protected to cross. He may ask a passerby for assist — solely to be ignored by some — or spend 5 to 10 minutes making an attempt to determine when it was protected to cross. 

Forzano, who efficiently requested indicators at different places, put within the request to SDOT. The placement hasn’t but been given a building date. 

“That was my commute day-after-day, twice a day,” mentioned Forzano, who has since moved to New York.

In Northgate, Thompson remains to be hoping for a brand new sign on the intersection close to her residence.

“I’m so glad that this world is making an attempt to make issues accessible,” she mentioned. “And it’s extremely irritating when one thing isn’t accessible.”