South Texas restrictions have been meant to guard folks from COVID-19. Then {the handcuffs} and ticket books got here out.


This text is co-published with ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Join ProPublica’s Massive Story e-newsletter to obtain tales like this one in your inbox as quickly as they’re revealed.

Additionally, join The Transient, our each day e-newsletter that retains readers up to the mark on essentially the most important Texas information.

The day that Dallas salon proprietor Shelley Luther was arrested for reopening her enterprise in defiance of Texas emergency stay-home orders, Robin Torres sat in a county jail 500 miles away going through the implications of his personal failure to observe such guidelines.

Luther turned a conservative darling this spring for her provocation, spending two days in custody on contempt of court docket costs. Largely in response to her case, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott finally prohibited the authorities from jailing anybody for violating the stay-home orders established to cease the unfold of COVID-19.

Torres, against this, spent 5 weeks within the Hidalgo County jail after a police officer caught him smoking and consuming a Busch Mild beer exterior a comfort retailer simply after 11 p.m. on April 3. Arrested on a public intoxication cost and for violation of the stay-home orders, Torres couldn’t afford to pay the $150 he owed on his bond. He wasn’t launched till early Might, sooner or later after Luther emerged from her temporary stint in jail as a star, a notoriety she became a run for a Texas Senate seat. In the meantime, circumstances like Torres’ have largely gone ignored.

“I believed I might solely spend the weekend in jail,” stated Torres, now 31, in a current interview. “I ended up spending greater than a month in jail.”

Torres was one among not less than 300 folks arrested for violating COVID-19 orders, usually along with different costs, within the first six weeks of the pandemic within the Rio Grande Valley, an investigation by ProPublica and The Texas Tribune discovered. Right here, in part of the state already teeming with legislation enforcement due to its location alongside the border with Mexico, officers took a number of the hardest strains on enforcement of COVID-19 guidelines in Texas. Altogether, authorities right here issued practically 2,000 citations to people for violating the orders, the investigation discovered.

These counties have been early adopters of curfews as a solution to include the virus. They banned nonessential journey, leading to lots of of people being stopped by legislation enforcement and ticketed. In not less than some circumstances, officers used the emergency order as a motive to cease somebody however then booked them for an additional, typically extra severe, cost. Or, they tacked on a cost or quotation for violating the emergency order even when it had little to do with the crime they have been investigating, a call that always elevated bail and made it more durable for folks to get out of custody.

The enforcement of COVID-19 emergency orders within the Rio Grande Valley final spring supplies a snapshot of what occurs when such directives are utilized steadily and, typically, aggressively. It raises questions in regards to the function legislation enforcement ought to play in addressing public well being and the toll this will tackle communities of coloration.

Months later, some folks cited for violations are nonetheless going through lots of of {dollars} in fines.

In Hidalgo County, the biggest within the Valley by inhabitants, the district lawyer’s workplace reviewed 116 circumstances the place folks have been arrested for violating the emergency administration plan. Amongst these circumstances, practically 3 in 10 folks have been charged just for the emergency order violation, the district lawyer stated.

In a single April case, Hidalgo County sheriff’s deputies arrested Jorge Gonzalez Zuniga after they discovered him intoxicated and handed out in a trailer park. An extended battle adopted, throughout which the deputies used a Taser to subdue Gonzalez. They booked him for violation of the emergency order, public intoxication and resisting arrest. Solely after a day in custody did deputies uncover that Gonzalez, an undocumented immigrant, had suffered a extreme spinal harm. He died in a hospital months later. After an investigation by the Texas Division of Public Security, a grand jury declined to indict the deputies, however Gonzalez’s household has filed a civil negligence declare towards the sheriff’s workplace, in response to an announcement from Sheriff J.E. “Eddie” Guerra.

Though a few of these arrested have been acquainted to police, the arrests additionally netted homeless folks, undocumented immigrants, individuals who have been probably sick with COVID-19, and a highschool scholar driving between his dad and mom’ homes as a part of a joint-custody settlement. The teenager stated he was instructed he owed $1,000.

A sign urges resident to stay safe during the COVID-19 pandemic in Hidalgo County. Dec. 7, 2020.

The robust legislation enforcement response within the Rio Grande Valley seems to distinction sharply with different elements of the state. Though enforcement of COVID-19 orders diversified considerably throughout Texas, its largest cities have been comparatively restrained of their strategy, notably within the preliminary months of the pandemic. In San Antonio, Texas’ second-largest metropolis, with 1.5 million folks, the Police Division issued simply 4 coronavirus-related citations in all of April, whereas Pharr, a metropolis of 80,000 within the Rio Grande Valley, issued not less than 115 throughout the identical time. Police in Austin, the state capital, issued six citations from the start of the pandemic till early December.

The big cities sometimes issued citations to companies and enterprise house owners solely after they repeatedly defied orders, if the cities gave them out in any respect. Some police departments gave express orders to officers to not arrest anybody for the emergency order cost.

Whilst distribution of COVID-19 vaccines begins, cities throughout the nation proceed to battle an enormous surge in virus infections, and a few have adopted hard-line lockdown approaches to tamp down the brand new wave. El Paso started to subject extra citations and imposed curfews after circumstances spiked there in October, although the state blocked the county’s shutdown of nonessential companies.

Public well being consultants interviewed for this story raised questions on criminalizing this type of habits and stated it may probably be harmful if it means folks spend time in jail. At the least 204 inmates in Texas jails and prisons died from COVID-19 between April 7 and Oct. 4, in response to a current research out of the College of Texas at Austin’s Lyndon B. Johnson College of Public Affairs.

Officers within the Rio Grande Valley interviewed for this story say their intentions have been by no means punitive however have been meant to fight a once-in-a-lifetime disaster. They identified that most people arrested have been charged with further, extra severe crimes. One stated their strict strategy was largely why COVID-19 circumstances have been comparatively low within the area till Abbott began lifting restrictions on companies in Might. By August, dying charges in Hidalgo County, the place Torres was arrested, had surged to 88 per 100,000, greater than 2½ occasions the speed statewide.

Additionally they word that most of the COVID-19 violation circumstances have been finally dismissed, together with Torres’. He was launched Might 8, court docket information present, “within the curiosity of justice,” after 34 days in custody.

Regardless of the dismissal, Torres’ court-appointed lawyer, Al Alvarez, argues that the prison justice system was by no means designed to guard folks from a virus.

“We wish safety,” Alvarez stated. “We don’t need abuses of the system.”

Extra accountability, and extra police

With practically 1.4 million folks, the four-county space that makes up the Rio Grande Valley, identified colloquially as “the Valley,” rivals massive cities like San Antonio and Dallas in inhabitants. However it’s a uniquely bicultural place, a patchwork of small and midsize communities that lie shoulder to shoulder alongside the southernmost strip of the Texas-Mexico border. Spanish is commonly a primary language.

It’s a place saturated with police, a mishmash of legislation enforcement companies — not simply native patrol however state troopers, federal narcotics brokers and immigration officers.

“Within the border cities, we’re nearly militarized,” stated Alvarez. “We’ve DEA [Drug Enforcement Administration], FBI, Homeland Safety, Border Patrol. We’ve tons of legislation enforcement companies, and so every thing turns into, we now have all this arsenal at our discretion, and so it whips all people up into, ‘What can we do to implement these emergency orders?’”

The early days of the pandemic have been a time of utmost uncertainty and concern within the Rio Grande Valley, as a result of the area’s excessive poverty and poor well being metrics put residents at notably excessive threat for an infection.

Whilst the whole state went into lockdown, some Valley communities went additional.

In late March, Hidalgo and Cameron counties, the area’s two inhabitants facilities, carried out nightly curfews. Certainly one of Cameron County Decide Eddie Treviño Jr.’s orders explicitly restricted the variety of folks in a automobile to 2 and, “when attainable,” no a couple of.

Treviño didn’t reply to a request for an interview or to questions despatched to his workplace by ProPublica/The Texas Tribune.

Some cities initiated roadblocks and checkpoints. In early April, Cameron County Sheriff Omar Lucio arrange a visitors activity power to subject tickets to motorists violating the stay-home order.

Officers argue the purpose of those efforts was to maintain residents secure.

“Since we didn’t know how one can cope with this, I took essentially the most conservative place that I may as a result of I knew the multiplier impact,” stated Hidalgo County Decide Richard F. Cortez. “The extra folks which are contaminated, the extra folks which are on the market that may infect others.”

Some legislation enforcement companies throughout the counties stated they have been cautious about how one can interpret shelter-in-place orders coming from the state and their very own county and municipal governments. Within the preliminary month of the virus’ unfold in Texas, orders have been popping out each few weeks and even days. Individuals may face both jail time or fines, relying on the circumstances.

The Texas authorities code defining violation of the emergency administration plan is a part of the state’s catastrophe act. Normally, the rule is utilized in conditions like hurricanes and wildfires. COVID-19 offered companies with a very totally different form of catastrophe, one which meant law enforcement officials needed to “blaze new trails,” stated Brownsville police Cmdr. William Dietrich. The strategy was to advise folks, and most complied.

When it was clear a sure section of the inhabitants wouldn’t observe the foundations, “that’s once we stated, ‘Hey, there’s going to need to be some form of enforcement exercise,’” Dietrich stated. His division beefed up patrols throughout in a single day curfew hours in Cameron County throughout the first section of the pandemic.

Edward A. Sandoval, the primary assistant district lawyer in Cameron County, stated that the orders have been “a device out there” to officers and that making use of them was at their discretion. In the end, these officers — many with little coaching on the emergency act legislation, and making an attempt to guard themselves within the pandemic — have been put able of turning into “public well being law enforcement officials,” Sandoval stated.

That heavy reliance on legislation enforcement was problematic as a result of the strategy must be a “public well being” one alone, stated John-Michael Torres, communications coordinator for La Unión del Pueblo Entero, a Valley-based group that does group organizing and advocates for undocumented folks. “They body it [as], they’re doing it to coach the general public in regards to the orders. In actuality, the police are there to police.”

Minor offenses, many arrests

Round 7:30 p.m. April 2, police from the town of Mission, in Hidalgo County, pulled over Jay Villalon, alleging that he was leaving a identified drug space when he must be at house.

Within the arrest report, the officer stated he was helping with the state-mandated curfew and requested Villalon, 21 on the time, if he was conscious of it. Villalon finally instructed the officer he had a vape pen in his pocket. The officer additionally discovered cartridges containing THC and just a little greater than an oz of marijuana. He arrested Villalon for violating the emergency plan, possession of marijuana and possession of a managed substance, a felony.

The felony cost, which continues to be pending, has triggered Villalon stress as a result of it’s “going to come back up each time, you realize, a cop searches you up or one thing, he desires to see your ID, he desires to run your title, and each time he runs your title he’ll be suspicious,” he stated. The emergency order violation was dismissed, in response to Hidalgo County information.

Jose Arturo Villalon, also known as “JAA”, outside of his home in Mission. JAA was stopped for violating a curfew order in H…

ProPublica and The Tribune couldn’t definitively decide how usually the emergency orders have been the rationale an officer made a cease, as a result of not each legislation enforcement company offered arrest narratives. Nevertheless, in two cities that offered this stage of element — Brownsville and Harlingen, each in Cameron County — emergency orders have been listed as the rationale for roughly 1 in 10 of the arrests.

Simply as officers can legally cease somebody they think of a criminal offense for small infractions like failing to make use of a flip sign, the violation of the emergency plan was but one more reason to cease somebody if that they had suspicions.

“We’re small cities,” stated Joe Reyna, one other non-public lawyer in Hidalgo County who represented a handful of individuals booked for the emergency order violation, costs that have been later dismissed. “The small cities know the folks residing within the cities, and so they determine, ‘Should you guys are breaking curfew, I’m going to lock them up for that, and possibly I’ll discover cocaine on them or discover marijuana on them.’ They’re utilizing it as a pretext.”

Ricardo Rodriguez Jr., the Hidalgo County district lawyer, stated his workplace made clear to legislation enforcement companies that they might not use the emergency order as “possible trigger to cease a automobile or an individual.”

ProPublica and the Tribune discovered that most often within the Valley, within the communities the information organizations analyzed, folks arrested for the violation, like Villalon, additionally confronted another form of prison cost. These costs ranged in severity, from public intoxication to DWI and assault.

However that was not all the time the case, particularly in Progreso, a metropolis in Hidalgo County with a inhabitants of about 6,000. Officers there stopped not less than 82 folks for violating the emergency plan. Practically half the stops had no secondary cost; the commonest further costs have been driving with no license and public intoxication.

Socrates Shawn, then an 18-year-old highschool senior, was driving from his father’s home in Progreso Lakes, a small group simply south of Progreso, to his mom’s place 24 miles away in McAllen. Shawn needed to spend particular days of the week with every mum or dad as a part of their divorce decree, which utilized till he completed highschool. So when a Progreso police officer stopped him on April 8 for violating state orders, Shawn assumed he’d get a slap on the wrist. The Hidalgo County curfew wouldn’t begin for 2 hours.

As a substitute, Shawn stated the officer instructed him he was underneath arrest. The officer wrote that Shawn’s offense was a “Keep at House Violation” on the report. “There was a ton of vehicles driving previous and I used to be like, ‘Why did not you pull them over?’” Shawn recalled. “He stated, ‘Nicely, we’re making an attempt to drag everybody over. You guys should not be driving.’” After about an hour and a half in a holding cell, Shawn stated an officer instructed him he simply needed to pay $1,000 to be launched, the utmost superb allowed for violating the order. He known as his dad, who stated in an interview with ProPublica and the Tribune that police instructed him he may pay with a cash order that night time.

Shawn was in a position to get out of jail with out instantly paying the cash, however he nonetheless owes the superb. Final he checked, it had gone as much as $1,313 as a result of, the town instructed him, he had missed a court docket date in June. Nevertheless, Shawn stated his court docket date was rescheduled a number of occasions, together with after he took off work sooner or later in June, solely to be taught the listening to was canceled. A collections company just lately contacted him, and he’s fearful {that a} warrant could possibly be issued for his arrest.

Progreso Police Chief Cesar Solis instructed ProPublica and the Tribune the cash was a bond to make sure folks confirmed as much as pay the fines in court docket. He stated officers had discretion whether or not to quote and launch or detain folks.

ProPublica and the Tribune interviewed two different individuals who, like Shawn, stated they have been instructed they must pay $1,000 for violating the stay-at-home order. One was selecting up dinner. The second was a person heading to the grocery retailer together with his 12-year-old son to select up substances for the night time’s carne dorada. In an interview, the person stated an officer stopped him and assessed him $1,000 for violating the stay-home order and $160 as a result of he doesn’t have a driver’s license.

“It was the primary time,” the person stated in Spanish. “I had by no means been warned.” He stated the officer let him go as a result of his son was within the automotive. Like Shawn, he stated that his court docket dates have been canceled a number of occasions however that he’s obtained a number of calls from a collections company.

Progreso’s municipal court docket was closed from April to July because of the pandemic, stated metropolis clerk Raul Garcia. The court docket resumed in August, at which period Garcia stated he started assessing failure-to-appear costs. The net fee system exhibits Shawn was issued a $430 cost in August for failing to seem earlier than the choose, however the different man was issued this cost in April, when Garcia stated the court docket was closed.

Subsequent door, in Cameron County, Brownsville police arrested not less than 25 folks just for violating the emergency administration plan, together with a homeless man twice inside weeks.

On April 4, simply earlier than midday, the person instructed a police officer he was panhandling to gather sufficient funds to purchase meals. “He was asking for cash and was out on the road for a nonessential objective,” the officer wrote within the arrest report.

Then, simply earlier than 8 a.m. April 22, a distinct Brownsville police officer noticed the person on the identical intersection. He instructed him he needed to be “wherever he sleeps at” and never strategy autos. The person was arrested once more.

Dietrich, the Brownsville police commander, stated there’s a massive shelter in Brownsville the place homeless folks may have gone, “however these people are selecting to not be at these areas and to be out on the street.” He stated the division prioritized arresting folks for violent crimes and the emergency orders on this interval to maintain the jails much less crowded.

All instructed, Brownsville police handed out greater than 600 tickets from mid-March to the top of April, a method that Dietrich stated was one of many solely methods to get compliance.

Sandoval, with the Cameron County district lawyer’s workplace, stated he couldn’t touch upon the Brownsville arrests as a result of he had not seen the studies. Nevertheless, he stated, “we don’t need … somebody’s financial situation to be the idea of punishment. They should not be punished as a result of they don’t have a house.”

The Brownsville Police Station. Dec. 8, 2020.

Generally, folks did flout the foundations. In Weslaco, in Hidalgo County, police have been known as to a Walmart as a result of a person refused to put on a masks and stated his constitutional rights have been being violated. A battle ensued, and an officer used a Taser on the person.

However utilizing coercion measures, like arrests and citations, isn’t a sensible solution to management the virus, stated Gregg S. Gonsalves, an assistant professor on the Yale College of Public Well being. “If we’ll strategy the management of COVID-19, it should be on this complete method, largely by incentivizing habits change, not shaming and blaming and arresting folks for it,” Gonsalves stated. “Getting police concerned in public well being is just not a good suggestion.”

Arresting folks throughout the pandemic additionally raises main considerations as a result of jails and prisons, notably in Texas, have been hotbeds for the virus.

Villalon, who was arrested in Mission, was transferred to the Hidalgo County Jail, the place he stated he was positioned in a cell with dozens of different folks with no hand sanitizer, no masks for him and different prisoners and no social distancing. Three folks interviewed by ProPublica and The Tribune stated they have been both not given masks or solely given masks as soon as they started working on the jail throughout their time in custody.

The Hidalgo County sheriff’s workplace declined to be interviewed for this story.

Fines pile up, and circumstances are dismissed

Outcomes for violating COVID-19 orders diversified from group to group within the Valley.

Daisy Alvarado was one among greater than 340 folks cited by Cameron County sheriff’s deputies for violating COVID-19 orders. She was stopped whereas driving house from dropping off some drugs she’d picked up at Walmart for her grandfather. However Alvarado didn’t have the receipts from Walmart — she stated she left them together with her grandfather — so she had no proof what she was doing was important.

“It wasn’t truthful as a result of I did it for a motive,” stated Alvarado, 26, who stated she not often goes wherever now as a result of she had a child woman in August. “There was quite a lot of different autos. Who is aware of the place they have been going.”

Alvarado now owes Cameron County greater than $750 for the ticket, which elevated on account of assortment charges, a Cameron County court docket staffer stated. She stated she didn’t know that till she was instructed by a ProPublica/Tribune reporter. She was one among practically 200 folks ticketed by the sheriff’s division for emergency order violations who owed greater than $700 as of mid-November.

Between late March and the top of April, the Hidalgo County sheriff’s workplace issued 125 citations to folks for violating emergency orders, whereas Cameron, instantly to the east, issued greater than 2½ occasions as many. That patchwork of guidelines may be problematic, stated Grant M. Scheiner, president of the Texas Felony Protection Legal professionals Affiliation. “How is a motorist purported to know what the foundations are in a jurisdiction and what the enforcement mechanism is?”

The fines that accompany these citations are “simply abominable,” stated Gonsalves, the professor from Yale, particularly throughout the best financial disaster for the reason that Nice Despair. “Punishing through the use of citations makes their financial lives much more precarious.”

The Cameron County sheriff’s workplace didn’t reply to requests for an interview.

Sandoval, the Cameron County first assistant DA, stated he didn’t know the county court docket had partnered with a collections company to ship letters to folks with excellent tickets till he was knowledgeable by ProPublica and the Tribune. He was “involved” by the letters as a result of it’d suggest to somebody they have been responsible of a criminal offense once they haven’t but gone to court docket. “Our curiosity is the pursuit of justice, it’s not essentially the superb,” he stated.

His workplace finally dismissed all 34 circumstances it obtained wherein somebody was charged with violation of the emergency order. He would have most popular if each officer had filed these violations as tickets. “We don’t profit from folks being in jail,” he stated. However, he famous that in 31 of the circumstances his prosecutors dismissed, the defendants have been charged with further crimes.

He talked in regards to the arrests when it comes to the devastation felt by Valley residents over the past yr. “There’s some people which have determined that they are extra vital than the group, and so they constantly make selections that put their self-interest forward of the entire,” Sandoval stated. “That has resulted with the dying of individuals, our mates, our household and our family members.”

First Assistant District Attorney Edward A. Sandoval outside of the Cameron County courthouse on Dec. 8, 2020.

Hidalgo County prosecutors dismissed 22 of the 34 circumstances wherein a defendant was charged solely with the emergency order violation. 9 are nonetheless pending disposition. Three folks pleaded responsible to the cost. Rodriguez, that county’s district lawyer, stated he didn’t know why the person prosecutors dismissed the circumstances however stated he felt all had been dealt with appropriately based mostly on the orders within the county.

Accessible information point out arrests for violation of the orders appeared to cease by late April within the Valley. COVID-19 continued, ravaging the area over the summer time. Now it’s spiking once more. So far, Hidalgo County alone has reported 1,889 deaths from the virus, the second-highest whole within the state, whereas Cameron County was seventh. Within the final week, Cortez, the Hidalgo County choose, introduced he had examined optimistic for the virus. Final month, the county sheriff had it.

Alvarez, Torres’ lawyer, just lately mourned a fellow lawyer who died from COVID-19 on the age of 45. He is aware of many individuals within the prison justice system who’ve misplaced family members to the illness. Torres stated he examined optimistic for the virus this summer time whereas ready to start therapy for most cancers.

The virus’ toll hasn’t modified Alvarez’s opinion that guidelines just like the emergency orders have to be utilized cautiously. Everyone seems to be affected, he stated, “and the defendants are those who’re extra impacted as a result of they’re those which are within the threat of dropping their liberty.”

“You don’t have to make use of the total power of the legislation, the hammer of the legislation, simply to implement one thing that’s a well being subject,” he stated.

Supply hyperlink